Days of our lives spoilers: RUMOR! James Scott comeback to DOOL and takes on a very interesting role

👑 A DiMera Legacy Reimagined: From EJ to Stefano?

Since his debut in 2006, James Scott’s EJ DiMera has been a cornerstone of Days of Our Lives. Seductive, ruthless, and emotionally complex, EJ was the ultimate antihero. Scott’s chemistry with Alison Sweeney’s Sami Brady gave fans one of the greatest supercouples in soap history. His departure in 2014 was a major blow, and while Dan Feuerriegel has stepped into the role of EJ since 2021, the shadow of Scott’s original portrayal still looms large.

But now? The rumor mill suggests that James Scott could return to the canvas — not as EJ, but as the resurrected Phoenix himself, Stefano DiMera.

Could EJ’s body be used as a vessel for his father’s dark soul? In Salem, absolutely.

🕊️ The Phoenix Factor: Why Stefano’s Resurrection Makes Sense

Let’s not forget: Stefano is never really gone. The legendary Joseph Mascolo portrayed the villain from 1982 until his death in 2016, crafting one of the most iconic soap villains of all time. Stefano’s ability to “rise from the ashes” — quite literally — earned him the nickname The Phoenix, and Days has a long track record of insane-but-awesome sci-fi twists.

• Cloning? ✔️
• Devil possession? ✔️
• Face swapping and brainwashing? ✔️✔️

So why not soul transference, again? Remember the “Stevano” arc where Stefano’s essence took over Steve Johnson’s body? Wild, yes. But undeniably Days.

🧠 The Case for James Scott as Stefano DiMera

Here’s why this theory has fans buzzing:

• Familiarity with the role: Scott was EJ — a DiMera through and through. He understands the tone, the gravitas, and the sinister glamour the DiMera name demands.
• Fan nostalgia: His return could reignite lapsed viewers and draw fresh attention to the show, especially during its 60th anniversary run in 2025.
• Built-in drama: A Stefano-possessed EJ? Imagine Sami Brady confronting the love of her life, only to discover he’s become her worst enemy. That’s gold-plated daytime drama.

And let’s be real — seeing James Scott channel Mascolo’s essence with his signature smirk and chilling charisma? Instant ratings spike.

⚠️ The Reality Check: Will James Scott Actually Return?

Here’s the catch: James Scott has said “never, never, never” when asked about returning to Days or Hollywood.

Back in 2020, Scott made headlines when he publicly declared that he was done with acting, turning his focus to a more spiritual and private life through his business, The Whisper Within. He’s been clear and consistent about his departure from the industry — seeking peace over performance.

So… is there any hope?

In soaps, never rarely means never. Countless stars have vowed never to return, only to come back when the story was right, the timing was perfect, or the fans demanded it.

If there were ever a role juicy enough to tempt James Scott back? It’s Stefano DiMera.

🌪️ Fan Frenzy: What Social Media Is Saying

Over on platforms like X (formerly Twitter) and Reddit, fans are lit with speculation:

“If James Scott came back as Stefano? I’d watch every single episode again. No hesitation.”

“Bring back the Phoenix, give him a new face. Let it be EJ’s. Let it be Scott.”
“Scott returning would be the biggest soap twist in 10 years.”

🤔 Other Contenders: If Not Scott, Then Who?

If Scott remains firm in his retirement, who else could play Stefano?

SoapSheKnows.com has floated names like:

• Vincent Irizarry (ex-Deimos, Days)
• Anders Hove (Faison, GH)
• Robert Kelker-Kelly (ex-Bo, Days)

All solid soap vets. But none have Scott’s built-in emotional connection to the DiMera family. Casting him would be both nostalgic and revolutionary.

Another bold possibility? A younger Stefano via a time-twist or Reverse SORAS storyline. Risky — but Days has pulled off crazier.

🧭 What It Means for Days’ Future

Bringing Stefano back — especially in James Scott’s form — would be more than a twist. It would be a return to roots. The DiMera family has floundered without its patriarch. With the show heading toward a major anniversary, this could be the storyline that revitalizes the franchise.

Imagine:

• Chad, Kristen, Tony, and EJ all wrestling with the return of their father — but in EJ’s body.
• Sami pulled into the chaos, caught between past love and present evil.
• Power struggles erupting at DiMera Enterprises and across Salem.

It’s not just soap — it’s Shakespearean.